Summary: By lowering costs and improving retention.
Manager, Special Gifts,
Dallas Symphony Association, wrote to CYBERGIFTS on September 22, 2000:
I am looking for statistics to support my case that online fundraising is
profitable, that it increases renewals rates and the volume of new donors.
Does anyone know where I could find such statistics? Do any of y'all have
anecdotes or statistics you could share? Any information is appreciated!!
Founder & CEO,
Convio, Inc - the Online Partner for Nonprofits,
A study by PBS stations doing a web research initiative showed that 49% of
online donors were new. I personally believe this is because of the added
convenience of giving online.
In terms of retention/renewal rates, there is not much data that I have seen
on the market for organizations yet, though many groups we have spoken to
have done the math to show that a small percentage increase in retention
rate drops straight to the bottom line, and has a huge impact. An
organization that we interviewed in Boston cited that they calculated that a
4% increase in retention rate from their current 56% would have close to a
30% impact on their bottom line. Citing James Greenfield (author of
Fundraising, and contributor to the AHP journal), typical direct mail based
donor acquisition rates are $1-1.50 per dollar raised, vs. retention costs
of $0.20-0.25 per dollar.
Internet based fundraising not only allows renewal/retention at a much lower
cost than the traditional 20-25 cents per dollar, but more importantly
changes the equation - by increasing retention, and therefore the
profitability of dollars raised. Renewal is made even easier for returning
donors/members on-line, if you do not make them re-complete their contact
information - in other words present a blank donation form, but can remember
who they are and prefill the form - this is what commercial websites like
Amazon.com do. For an example of a nonprofit organization who is now doing
this, register and try to give online to this Children's Museum -
Renewal is also more effect when the Internet (both your website and email)
is used as a cultivation, relationship management and stewardship tool vs.
purely for solicitation. Studies consistently show that donors want to see
where their funds are being spent.
An economic study that I read also empirically showed that renewal rates are
higher when donors receive "thank-you" acknowledgements. Most organizations
do this by paper, but it often takes weeks, is costly and requires people.
Giving immediate, personalized thank-you's online and via email gives
immediate gratification to the donor and enhances the propensity for donors
Additionally, some studies have shown that response rates on email or mixed
email/direct mail campaigns is higher than pure direct mail. A study run by
Stanford University showed that in 2 test cells of 500, the response rate
when using email was 2x that of purely direct mail. In their case, they
personalized both the direct mails and emails with the donor name and last
year's gift. We all know the benefits of personalization and impact on
response rates. In their case, they had to do this manually, but there is
now a simpler, more cost efficient way to do so with Convio's Email
Marketing technology - part of our Relationship Management System.
Moreover, there are many lessons to learn from the "for-profit" space on the
subject of loyalty and retention. My favorite book on the subject, is the
Loyalty Effect by Fred Reicheld.
The Loyalty Effect from Amazon.Com. A royalty will be paid
which will help support the Internet Nonprofit Center.)
Posted 9/22/00 -- PB
Feedback: Please take a moment to give us feedback on this item. This link will open up an email to the editors, with some structured feedback questions. Otherwise, for comments about the content of this, or any other page on the site, please email the Editor. For comments about the functionality of the site, please email the Webmaster. When writing, please be sure to give us the exact URL of the item you are looking at and a full description of the problem you encountered.
Copyright notice: The Internet Nonprofit Center, the Nonprofit Locator, the Library, and the Form 990 Project are projects of The Evergreen State Society, in Seattle, WA, USA. These pages copyright, 2002. Material by others
included here is copyright by the original author unless otherwise specified. For reprint permission, please email the Editor.